Elliott Abrams

Pressure Points

Abrams gives his take on U.S. foreign policy, with special focus on the Middle East and democracy and human rights issues.

Print Print Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close


Israel: BDS in the West, Integration in the Middle East?

by Elliott Abrams
July 7, 2014


Efforts continue in Europe and the United States to boycott Israel or at least Israeli goods “tainted” by their production in settlements in the West Bank, and to disinvest in Israeli companies or in U.S. firms doing business there. Most recently, the Presbyterian Church USA joined in, voting that it would divest its shares in Caterpillar Inc., Hewlett-Packard and Motorola Solutions because of their sales in Israel.

But in the Middle East, the trend seems to be exactly opposite. This week, Egypt’s petroleum minister announced that Egypt would be buying Israeli natural gas. Why? Because Egypt needs energy supplies, and Israel is the logical supplier of gas. British Gas, the UK company, will extract the gas from Israeli sites in the Mediterranean and bring it by pipeline to Egypt. Here is part of the story in the Daily News, an Egyptian paper:

Minister of Petroleum and Mineral Resources Sherif Ismail does not mind allowing British BG Group to import gas from Israel…. “As the Minister of Petroleum, I remain of the opinion that there is no problem in letting BG Group import Israeli gas to protect Egypt from international fines and arbitration,” Ismail added. The company has not yet requested the government to begin the process of importing gas, he said, and it will only be allowed to import after approval and the signing of an agreement with the Egyptian government. “There is no embarrassment in Egypt using the gas the BG Group imports from Israel given our economic issues,” the minister went on. He stated that politically speaking, the president and the government working indirectly with Israel “is no longer taboo”. “Whatever is in Egypt’s interest must be implemented immediately as we are dealing with an energy crisis,” the minister said.

Meanwhile, the important travel of trucks between Turkey and Jordan has become impossible due to the war in Syria. The solution: send them by ship to Haifa. From there they can drive east into Jordan. Here is part of the Reuters story:

The hydraulic ramp of a Turkish freighter taps down on the eastern Mediterranean port of Haifa and, under a full moon, 37 trucks roll off onto an otherwise empty pier. In a convoy that stretches hundreds of meters, the trucks travel east across northern Israel, bringing goods from Europe to customers in Jordan and beyond. Until three years ago the cargo these trucks carry – fruits, cheese, raw material for the textile industry, spare parts, and second-hand trucks – would have come through Syria. But civil war has made that journey too perilous….Three years after Syria plunged into violence, Israel is reaping an unlikely economic benefit. The number of trucks crossing between Israel and Jordan has jumped some 300 percent since 2011, to 10,589 trucks a year, according to the Israel Airports Authority. In particular, exports from Turkey – food, steel, machinery and medicine – have begun to flow through Israel and across the Sheikh Hussein Bridge to Jordan and a few Arab neighbors. Turkey’s Directorate General of Merchant Marine, part of that country’s transport ministry, said that transit containers shipped to Israel for passage on to other countries increased to 77,337 tonnes in 2013 from 17,882 tonnes in 2010.

These are relatively small numbers, but these two items–gas to Egypt, trucks to Jordan–suggest that economic necessity is pushing these Middle East countries together. Meanwhile, they share some common enemies too, above all the jihadis of ISIS and al-Qaeda. The blind moralists of the PCUSA and other promoters of doing less business with Israel might take note. History is not on their side, nor economics, nor security needs–nor, of course, is their selective moralizing persuasive. It is reassuring that while they vote their prejudices, in the Middle East the Israeli gas will flow and the trucks will sail into and roll out of Haifa.

Post a Comment 5 Comments

  • Posted by John Celmanski

    Type your comment in here…I am sick and tired of the hypocritical stand of the world about Israel especially about the bds investments

  • Posted by SAS

    The world should continue to boycott Israel in all forms until it learns to respect Palestinian rights. Given the bestial behaviour we are seeing in Gaza, we have reason to believe that will not happen any time soon.

  • Posted by Barry Mack

    “History is not on their side, nor economics, nor security needs–nor, of course, is their selective moralizing persuasive.”

    Time will tell. I’m placing my bet on the opposite side in relation to West Bank settlements. I think the Israel economy is vulnerable to economic pressure from the West – itself rather tied of some people’s rather self-righteous and “selective moralizing”.

  • Posted by Adam

    I second that emotion. It’s time that BDS activities be labelled as the anti-semitic and immoral actions that they are. Picking on Israel at the exclusion of the rest of the ME is pure bigotry. No more double standards.

  • Posted by Asian Joe

    Asia is now Israel’s second largest market, surpassing the U.S, and next year it will surpass the E.U. as Israel’s largest trading

    Asia with 4 billion people, is the planet’s largest market–period.
    China is the second largest economy, followed by Japan in third place.

    The Israelis have signed gas deals with it’s Arab neighbors to the tune of billions.

    Europe is languishing in the doldrums, to possibly never recover from it’s recession.
    So go ahead with your BDS, the West is becoming more irrelevant here, in Asia. It would be interesting to hear what you people will say, when ISIS hits your doorsteps very soon.

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required