Isobel Coleman

Democracy in Development

Coleman maps the intersections between political reform, economic growth, and U.S. policy in the developing world.

Print Print Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close


Iran’s Green Movement: Awaiting Another Spark

by Isobel Coleman
June 14, 2011

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad speaks during a news conference in Tehran June 7, 2011. No offer from world powers could persuade Iran to stop enriching uranium, Ahmadinejad said on Tuesday. (Caren Firouz/Courtesy Reuters)

Sunday, June 12 marked the second anniversary of Iran’s disputed 2009 presidential election that sparked massive public demonstrations, resulting in the arrest of more than 5,000 people and a surge in politically motivated executions. To mark the anniversary last year, Green Movement leaders Mir Hossein Mousavi and Mehdi Karroubi toyed with organizing big protests but ultimately called them off as authorities made it clear that no dissent would be tolerated. This year, there has been even less room for protest. Both Mousavi and Karroubi are under house arrest. They and their wives have been held since February, without any charge or trial, after calling for protests in solidarity with the Arab Spring. The Coordination Council of the Green Path of Hope, the Green Movement’s decision-making body, invited Iranians to participate in a “silent march” through the heart of Tehran on Sunday. Thousands braved their way into the streets, walking quietly and wearing green scarves with their hands and faces painted green, some with photos of Mousavi pinned to their clothes. But far fewer than the million people the Green Movement had hoped for appeared. Still, the government took no chances. It lined the streets with security forces that in many spots seemed considerably to outnumber the silent marchers.

While critics contend that the Green Movement is effectively dead, Iran’s government doesn’t think so.  It continues to arrest even peaceful protesters and deals harshly with any dissidents. In the past few weeks, two high-profile activists have died protesting the regime. Reza Hoda Saber, a dissident journalist and Green Movement activist, just died of a heart attack in Evin Prison in Tehran after a 10-day hunger strike. His strike was to protest the death of Haleh Sahabi, who died after a beating by security forces at the funeral of her father. Some have been calling Haleh the new “Neda,” after Neda Agha-Soltan, the young woman whose tragic death at the height of the Green Movement demonstrations was captured on video and watched around the world.

Earlier this spring, I interviewed Nobel Peace Prize winner and human rights activist Shirin Ebadi, who insisted that “Iran is like a fire under the ashes. Any wind can again blow the flames.” The biggest wind to rattle the region in decades has been blowing with the Arab Spring, but sadly that has not been sufficient to unleash the people protests necessary to bring down the brutal regime in Tehran. As the Arab Spring turns to fall in many places–the ongoing civil war in Libya, the bloody fighting in Syria, and the disintegration of Yemen–any chance of its reviving the Green Movement in Iran has long passed. Instead, Iran’s embattled protest movement will have to find a different energy.

As the Green Movement struggles to define itself, the coalition of hardliners running the government in Tehran is beset by infighting and growing economic challenges. A few months ago, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad publicly bragged that “Iran is among the few countries in the world where no one goes to bed hungry.” He also claimed that he would eliminate unemployment within two years. He was roundly mocked at home for these patently empty statements. Young Iranians remain particularly frustrated, not only with a lack of personal freedoms, but also with their bleak economic prospects. No one can predict what will be the spark that sets off the flames of Iranian protest again, but it is likely to be fueled by a desire for both greater freedom and better economic opportunities.

Post a Comment 3 Comments

  • Posted by John Smith

    America should attack Iran.

  • Posted by hass

    The “Green Movement” is mostly an creation if hyped Western media and Iranian exile wishful thinking. Poll after poll by US organizations concluded that Ahmadinejad was the real winner of the elections, and no one has been able to provide any actual evidence of election fraud. Mousavi, the ostensible leader of the Greens, is himself a regime-insider and hardly a dissident. And far from having “bleak” economics, Iran has had a higher GDP growth rate than the US, and Iranians today live longer, have better access to healthcare, higher education, paved roads, clean water, and electricity than ever before. Even the IMF just congratulated Iran on its economic successes. It us tome to drop these bsloney make believe narratives about Iran and face some hard facts. And oh, BTW, Iran’s nuclear program is massively popular amongst the people, and Ahmadinejads opponents, even Mousavi, are actually more hardline on thst issue than he is.

  • Posted by hass

    By the way, the claim by the NY Times thst “thoudands” demonstrated is laughed at. Anonymous “opposition forces” have a habit of claiming such things.

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required