Isobel Coleman

Democracy in Development

Coleman maps the intersections between political reform, economic growth, and U.S. policy in the developing world.

Print Print Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close


Egypt’s Worsening Economy

by Isobel Coleman
December 15, 2011

Egyptians shop for sportswear at informal vendors in downtown Cairo on October 17, 2011 (Jamal Saidi/Courtesy Reuters).

As Egypt began the second of three rounds of elections yesterday and commentators in and outside the country debate the prospects for democracy after large Islamist victories so far, its economic problems loom ever larger. As I wrote at the end of November, Egypt’s economic challenges include: a battered tourism industry, expensive food and fuel subsidies that are driving budget deficits, high yields on government debt, and most urgently, rapidly declining foreign currency reserves. To drive the point home, on Sunday, interim prime minister Kamal el-Ganzouri tearfully stated in a press conference that Egypt’s economy is “worse than anyone imagines.” Current estimates about Egypt’s foreign currency reserves surely factor into his sobering assessment. Today, a report was leaked that the government intends to cut expenditures by $3.3 billion, but indicated that the cuts would not hit health care, education, and pensions. According to the World Bank, Egypt spent 5 percent of its GDP on healthcare in 2009, and 3.8 percent on education in 2008. It seems possible, then, that Egypt may begin to cut its politically sensitive and popular subsidies, which are significant: currently, subsidies are about three times the size of the education budget.

Egypt’s short-term solutions to its economic troubles are limited and include substantial commitments of foreign aid that have yet to materialize. Egypt had hoped to obtain nearly $8 billion in assistance pledged by Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE, though this now seems unlikely. So far, Egypt has received just $1 billion, a funding lag linked to Saudi Arabia’s displeasure with Mubarak’s ouster and subsequent trial, according to statements made by Western diplomats. In the coming months, Egypt’s funding from the United States (totaling about $1.8 billion in the FY2012 budget request) also stands to suffer as members of Congress are wary of an Egyptian parliament dominated by Islamic political parties. As CFR’s Ed Husain noted, it is easy for U.S. lawmakers to “build up a case against the Muslim Brotherhood,” not to mention that budget constraints at home present a further disincentive.

The bottom line is that without getting the basics of the economy right, Egypt’s budding democracy will have no legs to stand on and no energy to propel it. At the heart of protesters’ demands in January were economic complaints: a lack of opportunity, poor standards of living, inadequate education, and rampant corruption. While this economic dissatisfaction was a major factor in overthrowing the regime, it will also be a major inhibitor to democracy consolidation.

An interesting book from Jan Teorell last year, Determinants of Democratization, argues that poor economic performance under autocracies can set off transitions to democracy, while strong economic performance under democracies helps them avoid reverting to authoritarianism. Based on this assessment, without an economic improvement, Egypt’s prospects for sustainable democracy look slim.

Post a Comment 1 Comment

  • Posted by Imran Riffat

    All indicators about the Egyptian economy point towards a grim scenario. The effects of the reported $3.3 billion cuts in government expenditure will only compound the plight of an average Egyptian. A decline in revenues from tourism as well as a decrease in FDI inflows will remain perniciously anemic until such time the tussle between the military and civil society is resolved. One can understand – without necessarily agreeing with – the wariness of the US Congress in accepting an Egyptian parliament dominated by Islamic political parties. But if the outcome of the elections is a true reflection of the will of the Egyptian people – conveyed through the sanctity of a transparent ballot box – then this throws a big challenge to the friends and well-wishers of Egypt to try and cobble a creative win-win response to the situation. It might sound more complex than it really is; notwithstanding a larger control of seats in parliament the “piety and holiness” of the religious parties is not going to provide food to the hungry and jobs to the unemployed. I view it as an opportunity to reconnect and re-engage with the 80 million Egyptians in a way which is both fair and respectful.

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required