Isobel Coleman

Democracy in Development

Coleman maps the intersections between political reform, economic growth, and U.S. policy in the developing world.

Print Print Email Email Share Share Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close

loading...

Thoughts on Tunisia’s Transition

by Isobel Coleman
October 9, 2012

Protesters set fire to the American School in Tunis on September 14, 2012, which was closed at the time, and took away laptops and tablet computers (Zoubeir Souissi/Courtesy Reuters). Protesters set fire to the American School in Tunis on September 14, 2012, which was closed at the time, and took away laptops and tablet computers (Zoubeir Souissi/Courtesy Reuters).

I was in Tunisia last week and met with a wide range of people, including business, government, and civil society leaders; educators, journalists, bloggers, university students, and Salafist youth; young people unemployed and looking for jobs, and graduates who have newly entered the workforce. Below are some reflections on what I heard:

  • Numerous Tunisians I spoke with sadly noted that they don’t recognize their country today. From the Salafist demonstrations that shut down Manouba University; to the attacks on artists and journalists for “harming public morals”; to the sacking of the U.S. Embassy and nearby American Cooperative School of Tunis a few weeks ago; to the recent case of the woman who after being raped by the police was accused of “indecency”–all of these and other incidents indicate a worrying rise of conservatism and rejection of modernity in what has always been thought of as the most progressive country in the region. As Amna Guellali of Human Rights Watch put it, “After Ben Ali, a veil has been lifted exposing multiple realities in Tunisia, and the conservative trend is gaining ground.”
  • Just about everyone I spoke with agreed that the Tunisian government was complicit in the attack on the U.S. Embassy. Numerous eyewitness accounts noted how the mob seemed pretty well organized. The protestors started out in downtown Tunis and spent hours marching to the embassy on the outskirts of the city. Some carried ladders for scaling walls; others were demonstrating along the way with Molotov cocktails in their hands–while government helicopters circled overhead watching it all unfold. Scores of demonstrators even arrived at the embassy in vans and buses. The police outside the embassy mostly stood by as the mob became more violent, smashed windows, set fire to buildings, and crossed the street to sack the American school. Some said the government failed to stem the violence because it’s afraid of taking on the Salafists; others interpreted the government’s response as a pure populist play to “The Street.” One senior Al Nahda member redirected the blame to the Ministry of Interior, which he accused of being under the control of remnants of the “deep state” that wants to embarrass the fledgling Al Nahda-led government and split it from its U.S. partner.
  • Other than the Salafist youth, everyone else I spoke with agreed that the recent attacks were a disaster for the country–that the violence tarnished the image of the revolution, added to uncertainty and mistrust, scared away much-needed international investment and tourism, and further incited violent elements in society. The embassy attack was just the latest, but most serious, episode of government complacency against the violent extremism that is gaining ground in Tunisia today.
  • In a group discussion with fifteen young people–all from the interior of the country–who had recently completed a training program with the Education for Employment Foundation and landed much-coveted jobs at an international printing company, almost all of them expressed continued hope for their country. Only one said he regretted the fall of Ben Ali–even as his peers nodded disapprovingly. I wasn’t sure he was being serious, but rather was choosing his most strident way to convey disappointment with the revolution. When I pressed these young people on what they wanted to be doing five years from now, more than half expressed their desire to leave the country. Of all the things I heard in Tunisia, that is perhaps the most worrying for the country’s future.

Post a Comment 2 Comments

  • Posted by Myriam

    This article show exactly the situation in Tunisia, and what we feel about it, we can not have a state of Law with islamists, the concept of “moderate Islamism” is an illusion.

    The country goes to the disaster because the members of the government do not have the skills to drive the country.

    Even Ben Ali, who was not educated, knew that to run the country properly, we had to use the best technocrats in the country!

  • Posted by Cere daniel

    Tunisia has set the best record of what the world always consider the best leadership without the will of the community.
    i want to study peace and conflict resolution.

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required

Pingbacks