Shannon K. O'Neil

Latin America's Moment

O'Neil analyzes developments in Latin America and U.S. relations in the region.

Print Print Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close


Latino Immigrants as Job Creators

by Shannon K. O'Neil
September 13, 2012

Oswaldo Alvarado helps customers at Importaciones Valentinas grocery and pinata store in Phoenix Oswaldo Alvarado helps customers at Importaciones Valentinas grocery and pinata store in Phoenix (Joshua Lott/Courtey Reuters).


CFR’s Renewing America initiative just released a new report by Alexandra Starr, a fellow at the New America Foundation, titled “Latino Immigrant Entrepreneurs: How to Capitalize on Their Economic Potential.” Through statistics and personal stories, the report explores Latino immigrant entrepreneurs’ growing contributions to the U.S. economy.

Contrary to many who assume Latino immigrants just take away American jobs, Hispanic immigrants have played an important role in helping to revive small U.S. towns. While many come to find work, they often create the positions themselves, opening up new restaurants, storefronts, and services that line small-town Main Streets. Big cities are no different. In fact, almost half of New York City’s small businesses are immigrant-run. The report finds that immigrant entrepreneurs often have a distinct advantage due their ability to understand and work within both the United States and their home countries, allowing them to appeal not only to immigrant communities within the U.S. but also to export markets back home. Due in part to these benefits (as well as geography), Mexican immigrants have taken the entrepreneurial lead, starting more new companies (in sheer number) than any other immigrant group. On average Hispanic-run enterprises are small, though 16 percent employ between one and twenty employees (similar to 21 percent of non-immigrant-run small businesses).

The report also lays out some of the obstacles Latino entrepreneurs face. They often struggle with limited access to credit, due to their immigration status or their unfamiliarity with non-traditional lenders (e.g. micro-loan organizations). Sluggish visa processing also hinders immigrants’ potential, slowing investment, and, in some cases, leading companies to form or relocate abroad. Starr highlights one such case in her recent Wall Street Journal article, telling the story of Pablo Ambram, an Argentinian entrepreneur. After participating in a prestigious business program in the U.S., Ambram was forced to move his fledgling company, Agent Piggy, back to South America. He found that filing immigration paperwork as the CEO of a small business would have been too costly and uncertain.

Political debates often characterize immigrants as workers, rather than as employers. Yet as this report shows, Latino immigrants of all skills sets are increasingly both. The challenge for U.S. policymakers is to encourage this dynamism and to nurture innovative Latino immigrant entrepreneurs, as their successes will benefit not only Latino communities but also the U.S. economy more broadly.

Post a Comment 2 Comments

  • Posted by wigglwagon

    This just more of the same old nonsense from the proponents of no borders.

    No matter how they spin it, illegal aliens do not create prosperity or jobs. Demand for goods and services is the only thing that creates a prosperous economy. Over inflating the supply of labor with illegal aliens only drives down wages and destroys benefits for American workers. That creates even less demand for goods and services which brings on another round of lay offs and even lower demand. It is a vicious never ending circle that is driving American standards of living down to the same as those in industrially undeveloped countries.

    Oh, that’s right, I forgot, we are an industrially underdeveloped country. We gave our textile mills and furniture factories and clothing factories and on and on the list goes, we gave all those to other countries. We now spend a BILLION dollars more every day than we take in. I wonder how long that business will stay in the black? Oh, that’s right, I for got, we are already in the RED.

  • Posted by magyart

    Immigrants don’t take anyone’s job, for they are here LEGALLY. However, ILLEGAL migrants take jobs and if they are entrepreneurial, operate illegally and many times compete unfairly.

Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required