CFR Presents

Renewing America

Ideas and initiatives for rebuilding American economic strength.

Print Print Cite Cite
Style: MLA APA Chicago Close


Policy Initiative Spotlight: Social Programs Funded by Success

by Steven J. Markovich
February 8, 2013

A homeless man makes his way down the street before sunrise (Mike Blake/Courtesy Reuters). A homeless man makes his way down the street before sunrise (Mike Blake/Courtesy Reuters).


Last month Harvard’s Kennedy School and the Rockefeller Foundation announced a program to provide free technical assistance to four states and local governments pursuing social impact bonds (SIBs), one of the first efforts in the United States to scale up an innovative tool for increasing the quantity and effectiveness of social spending. In announcing the program, Jeffrey Liebman, who oversees the effort, said that “social impact bonds bring together the public, private, and nonprofit sectors in a program designed to boost social innovation and direct public dollars to programs that work.”

SIBs are a relatively new phenomenon designed to funnel private investor money to social programs. The world’s first SIB was launched in September 2010 in the United Kingdom. Social Finance raised $8 million from a pool of 17 investors—mostly philanthropic institutions—to fund services to short-sentence male prisoners exiting Peterborough prison with the aim of keeping them out of prison in the future, thus saving money for the government. Funding will go to outside organizations providing the services, such as the YMCA.

Investors will fund the program for six years, and will only recoup their initial investment and earn a return if the program is successful at reducing recidivism. Currently 60 percent of short sentence prisoners re-offend within a year; if the program can reduce that by 7.5 percent, then the government will pay investors back their initial investment; if the program can exceed the goal, then investors will earn a greater return.

In the United States, Massachusetts has been a leader in SIB adoption. The state authorized funding up to $50 million over several years to reimburse investors in successful programs that deliver savings to the commonwealth, with programs targeted to needy groups such as the homeless. New York City and Minnesota have also set aside funding for SIBs.

While SIBs in theory only cost governments if they succeed, they may require higher implementation costs. A successful SIB requires not only service providers, but a willing pool of investors, a manager who coordinates activity and financing, and impartial evaluators who can judge the level of success of a program.

Still, there is significant excitement about the potential of SIBs to enhance certain kinds of social programs. An extensive report by the McKinsey and Company management consultancy found that homelessness, and juvenile and adult criminal justice, could be fertile ground for SIBs. The authors advised three core actions: “developing a robust education and communications plan, embracing SIBs primarily for their social (rather than financial) benefits, and paying careful attention to design and implementation.”

As this model spreads to American shores, the United Kingdom continues to innovate. Allia has launched the Future for Children Bond, which is the first SIB for retail investors rather than large philanthropic organizations. Individual investors who can afford a minimum of £15,000 can invest in a bond fund combining a more traditional loan to a provider of affordable housing with a SIB to deliver family support therapy to needy 11-16 year olds.

Post a Comment 1 Comment

  • Posted by tkauka

    This program would help the people of the Big Island of Hawaii. Crystal Meth use is among the top in the nation. I fear for our youth. During the month of January 2013 we may have experienced our first serial killer. Claude Keone Krause and his cousin Kawena Krause at last count are responsible for two extremely brutal violent murders along with numerous other felonies. Dante Gilman’s (son of late author Peter Gilman who wrote novel Diamond Head, starring Charleton Heston) home surveillance system recorded his murder. The murderers destroyed the cameras but never had a clue of its hard drive. While searching for Gilman’s remains a second corpse was discovered. Rumor is the Krause’ are responsible for this murder as well. Claude Krause was convicted of the brutal sexual assault of Mayapple McCullough a former crime victims advocate. Mayapple died in 2011. At the time of the rape ten years ago Claude was 20 years Mayapple 50 something. Drugs, guns, crimes related to drug activity-burglaries, robberies, thefts, assaults, UAC’s criminal property damage all on the rise. Homelessness in numbers I have never witnessed, whole family’s living under bridges. I can go on.

    There are many philanthropic groups locally, a potentially desirable investor pool. More service related outcomes from the public sector should be addressed. Non-profits though limited should be supported, possibly grant funding. There’s a huge need here for SIB type programs. Recidivism among offenders male/female are statistically proven, The increase of native Hawaiian women (per OHA) incarcerated with an alarming number of recidivists. Again drug use and the ease of availability of drugs is the most recurring theme in this particular group of repeat offenders.

    Can Hawaii become another state added to your list?


Post a Comment

CFR seeks to foster civil and informed discussion of foreign policy issues. Opinions expressed on CFR blogs are solely those of the author or commenter, not of CFR, which takes no institutional positions. All comments must abide by CFR's guidelines and will be moderated prior to posting.

* Required